Commerce Content is independent of Editorial and Advertising, and if you buy something through our posts, we may get a small share of the sale. Click here for more.

The Best Olive Oil Is California Olive Ranch, According To Our Readers

California Olive Ranch sautéed the competition in this week’s Co-Op to earn the title of our readers’ favorite olive oil.


The biggest problems with olive oil are freshness and providence. Too much olive oil is inferior quality and has taken far too long to get to you.

California Olive Ranch solves both of those problems by only sourcing American olives, and picking and pressing as soon as possible, with verified dates on the package.

Easily the best tasting olive oil for the money. To get better you would have to spend far more. And it’s won a ton of taste tests. It will change your expectations of olive oil. - Pedro S

The Everyday variety is mild and fresh, but they have a number of other blends and single-variety oils that have a much broader spectrum of flavor. - kvetcha

This. Shit’s good and somehow cheap too. - jamesdoesntcare

You can find California Olive Ranch at basically any grocery store in the country, but it’s also available on Jet and Amazon at (usually) reasonable prices.

If you’re a Costco shopper, their Kirkland-branded oil also had a strong showing.

Senior Director of Commerce | Send deal submissions to