With a comment feed full of really great suggestions, two very similar pumps rose to the top. The BGBGeneration ‘Treasure’ Pump and the Nine West ‘Flax’ Pump, are both pointed-toe pumps. The only major difference is the material: one suede, one leather.
The best part, for me, was the heel heights not being outrageous (3 1/2" and 4"). Here’s what you had to say about both of them:
I like the Nine West Flax heel. I have it in three colors. It’s only $69 on Zappos. I used to buy a ton of Nine West shoes and then gave up on them and started buying nicer brands but honestly the slightly more expensive shoes didn’t last any longer. Plus, I know I’m a 7 in Nine West so ordering online is easier. I have this heel in three colors - a black leather, a tan leather and then a black/grey leopard print. - EdnasEdibles
Seconding these- they were my absolute go to before I started buying Cole Haan, which I think are a bit more comfortable. If there’s a Nine West outlet store near you, you can usually get them for $40 or so, and potentially buy one get one half off. - chicago lawlyer
Not only are they timeless, they are comfy as hell and 20% off at Nordstrom right now. Way under your budget too! - Natnonymous
With both shoes being not only under $100, but under $70, you really can’t go wrong with either one. They’re comfortable, affordable, and chic as hell.